Sunday, November 22, 2026
48 °
Light Rain
Log in Subscribe

Sen. Baldwin authors federal Healthy H2O Act

Sen. Wimberger prepares innocent landowner legislation

Posted

NORTHEAST WIS. – Ensuring drinking water is healthy and free of contaminants takes more funds than many local communities have at the ready, but U.S. Sen. Tammy Baldwin is working to change this through national legislation, while state Sen. Eric Wimberger is preparing state legislation to provide for PFAS clean up without allowing innocent landowners to be held responsible.

Baldwin is a co-author with Susan Collins, a Republican from Maine, of the bipartisan Healthy Drinking Water Affordability Act or “Healthy H2O Act.” The act would provide U.S. Department of Agriculture grants to individuals and nonprofits in communities with 10,000 or fewer residents for water testing and point-of-entry treatment (POET) systems that remove contaminants from drinking water.

“All Wisconsin families, businesses and communities should trust that the water coming out of their faucets is safe to drink, but across our state, rural communities are struggling to identify and treat chemicals like PFAS that endanger our health, especially for children,” Baldwin said. “My bipartisan legislation ensures our small and rural communities aren’t left behind.”

Wimberger said he is preparing two state bills that would ensure innocent landowners don’t face retribution for a problem they didn’t cause.

“We’re talking [about] farmers and people who built on top of farms and took biosolids, people who are next to plumes or airports, or businesses who had nothing to do with it. They will be in a not-responsible category,” Wimberger said. “The state can go and continue to sue the multinational corporations that were doing PFAS and knew it was dangerous a long time ago and didn’t tell anybody.”

Currently, the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) is providing free bottled water to some residents where elevated levels of PFAS were detected outside of the plume, an area in the Town of Peshtigo where Johnson Controls’ Tyco unit has taken responsibility for PFAS contamination in groundwater. PFAS are per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances used in firefighting foam, coatings, water-resistant materials and other products. They’ve been linked to health issues, such as cancer, thyroid issues and neurological issues.

PFAS-contaminated biosolids spread on farmland in northeast Wisconsin has compounded the issue, said Wimberger, who sees Baldwin’s federal legislation for PFAS grants as help in addressing “a thorny problem” affecting Wisconsin. But, the grants should come with legal reforms, Wimberger said.

“Johnson Controls did not tell the City of Marinette to spread it on the farm fields. There’s a question of whether the City of Marinette would be responsible in an intervening act instead of Johnson Controls. The legal battles are going to be expensive. We shouldn’t drag innocent landowners into them.”

He said he would like to work with Evers on the language in the bills, but Evers hasn’t been responding.

Still, Evers has made some progress in understanding the issue from the farmers’ point of view. “He’s come around. He has decided farmers and people who have residences on farmland could be innocent landowners,” Wimberger said of Evers.

Farmers aren’t the only landowners who should be exempted from responsibility for contaminations they didn’t cause, Wimberger said.

“Think of those who live in the Town of Peshtigo just outside of the plume where Johnson Controls has accepted responsibility for a PFAS contamination. While the DNR is providing free bottled water to some residents where elevated levels of PFAS were detected, others don’t qualify but could in the future.”

Wimberger said his legislation is timely because the U.S. EPA is expected to set the criteria level for PFAS at the surface level at 8 ppt. “There’s going to be a federal number that comes out and we’re going to be obligated by law to pick that up. We’re going to have a very low standard regardless of what the governor or legislature does,” he said.

Wimberger said the Wisconsin DNR has permitted 150,000 ppt at the surface level with 1.5 dry tons of biosolids per acre. “That’s all going to sink into the dirt,” he said. A DNR report published in March 2024 confirmed the DNR allowed this level of PFOS and PFOA in biosolids.

With the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s opinion in the Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce v DNR case strengthening the Spill Law and the DNR’s ability to enforce PFAS spills, Wimberger envisioned the DNR surveying to locate PFAS, then doing a water table layer investigation to assign responsibility based on probable cause innocent people are emitters. “It’s going to destroy them. That’s not right. It doesn’t have to be that way,” Wimberger said. “Businesses who didn’t have anything to do with the contamination should be innocent landowners.”

While the 2025-27 biennium budget includes over $1.8 million for the DNR to improve its customer service and systems in part by hiring additional personnel, Wimberger said he wants to change the grant-funding process so innocent landowners who apply for grants to clean up PFAS they didn’t cause aren’t unnecessarily disadvantaged by it. The grants Baldwin is advocating for require public applications that disclose addresses where PFAS was detected, potentially affecting the real estate’s value.

The grant funds should come with some legal reforms protecting innocent landowners from future responsibility, said Wimberger.
Currently to apply for a state grant, the landowner has to tell the DNR they have a contaminated well. They may receive a responsible party letter with their grant, he said. “The devastating part is not necessarily what the DNR does to them immediately but it could be in the future. You have to tell your bank or your future buyer that anyone who owns it becomes a responsible party. It’s going to devastate the property values,” he said.

The biennium budget also includes $731.6 million in borrowing for the state’s Environmental Improvement Fund, which secures federal clean water grants to help communities improve their water systems and infrastructure to ensure the drinking water is clean and safe to drink. “It’s a revolving loan fund where the State of

Wisconsin will leverage its bonding authority for $700 million and localities can apply for those funds at a very, very low interest rate.

That’s going to save localities tens of millions of dollars,” Wimberger said.

Evers said in a statement he will continue to press for the release of $125 million in PFAS remediation funding for local communities approved two years ago in the previous biennium. Wimberger said he put those funds in a trust fund, where they’ve grown to $128 million with interest.

U.S. Sen. Tammy Baldwin, Sen. Eric Wimberger, state legislation, PFAS clean up, landowners, Collins, drinking water, communities, Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources,

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here