NORTHEAST WIS. – While Gov. Tony Evers hopes to exempt PFAS legislation from the Wisconsin REINS Act, Republican legislators from northeast Wis. are preparing new PFAS legislation with their own exemptions centering on the definition of “innocent landowner” but omitting limits for specific per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances.
“My colleagues and I are again introducing PFAS relief legislation, providing local governments and landowners with the guidelines and resources they need to responsibly test, treat and remediate these chemicals from Wisconsin’s land and waters, both now and into the future,” state Sen. Eric Wimberger (R-Oconto) said in a Feb. 14 statement.
State Rep. Jeff (R-Crivitz) also is working on PFAS legislation with a “clearer definition identifying who qualifies as an innocent landowner,” he said in recent correspondence.
“As I’ve said many times, including to the Governor himself, my goal is to get legislation passed so that we can help the people in and around the 36th Assembly District get the help they need to clean up the PFAS contamination and stop it from spreading,” Mursau said. “I am hopeful that this updated bill draft can get us across the finish line and get the money out the door and get this process started.”
PFAS have been used in a wide range of products, such as nonstick coatings, some coated paper and foam used for firefighting, which is thought to be the source of the PFAS contamination in Marinette County. The chemical substances have been linked to many different health conditions, including neurodevelopmental issues, thyroid and kidney conditions and cancer.
If the two parties agree on any aspect of PFAS legislation, it’s that it is taking too long to address the issues.
“For too long, communities across Wisconsin have been hurting from PFAS contamination infiltrating public water systems and private wells. Testing and treating bodies of water impacted by these ‘forever chemicals’ can be incredibly expensive, especially for innocent landowners whose property contains PFAS through no fault of their own,” Wimberger said.
Marinette Common Council Member Doug Oitzinger, a member of Save Our Water (SOH20), asked Gov. Evers Feb. 4 in Marinette whether it would take 30 months after the budget is passed for groundwater standards to be considered. The PFAS contamination that Johnson Controls’ Tyco unit has taken responsibility for dates back to 2017, if not earlier.
“We have four people here from Save our Water who have been working on this since 2017. That’s more than seven years. In another 30 months, it will be 10. We don’t really find that an acceptable solution, that if you find out your well has been poisoned and right now, seven-and-a-half years later there’s been no standard on groundwater” passed, Oitzinger said. His comments preceded the governor’s quiet announcement he would include PFAS regulations in the Budget Bill and exempt them from the REINS Act, which requires legislature approval for new statutes with compliance costs of over $10 million.
At the meeting with Evers, Marinette County Supervisor and former State Rep. Stan Gruszynski said about PFAS regulations, “This should have been handled a long time ago…I don’t understand why that’s not getting talked about more because that’s where the problem lies,” he said. “This is a life and death matter going forward into our children’s lives and our grandchildren’s lives – and they’re playing with it.”
Wendy Dzurick, former Marinette Public School District superintendent, asked, “Is there a possibility to put out there about doing some research? Because this is -- as Stanley has said -- ground zero.”
Dzurick thanked Evers for making a trip to Marinette County “because rural areas sometimes get forgotten. There are a lot of families who live where they don’t have any access to city water,” she said. The water issue is a children’s health issue, she said. “I appreciate you labeling this the Year of the Kid. While we can take care of all of us, we need to change our future for all of those kids.”
While Republicans criticized Evers for vetoing SB 312 PFAS legislation last year, Evers said he did so because the legislation wouldn’t hold responsible parties accountable and it provided little incentive for them to clean up their act.
Wimberger also has criticized Gov. Evers for refusing to define “innocent landowners” who would be exempt from responsibility for possessing land contaminated by PFAS they didn’t cause. He said he has proposed a separate piece of legislation to define this term, but this wasn’t immediately available.
In draft legislation for the Wisconsin Assembly, Mursau exempts the following categories of people from Spill Law accountability:
1. A person that spreads biosolids or wastewater residuals contaminated by PFAS in compliance with any applicable license or permit.
2. A person that owns land upon which biosolids or wastewater residuals contaminated by PFAS were spread in compliance with any applicable license or permit.
3. A fire department, public-use airport, or municipality that responded to emergencies that required the use of PFAS or that conducted training for such emergencies in compliance with applicable federal regulations.
4. A solid waste disposal facility that accepted PFAS.
5. A person that owns, leases, manages, or contracts for property on which the PFAS contamination did not originate, unless the person also owns, leases, manages, or contracts for the property on which the PFAS discharge originated.
Unlike the Budget Bill, which Evers said would contain PFAS criteria mirroring federal standards, the Republican draft legislation doesn’t include PFAS limits.
The U.S. EPA has an open public-comment period until Feb. 24 to solicit feedback on water-and-organism human health criteria of 0.0009 ng per liter for PFOA, 0.06 ng/L for PFOS and 400 ng/L for PFBS, according to a Federal Register document.
The draft criteria for fish and shellfish, or organism-only human health criteria, are 0.0036 ng/L for PFOA, 0.07 ng/L for PFOS and 500 ng/L for PFBS, according to a Federal Register document.
The EPA used 90th-percentile per-capita consumption rates for fish, shellfish and drinking water and a mean body weight for adults to come up with the criteria, according to Bruno Pigott, then principal deputy assistant administrator for the EPA. To provide a comment, use Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OW-2024-0454, and visit https://www.regulations.gov.
Thousands of synthetic chemicals classified as PFAS have been used since the 1940s to withstand heat and repel water or stains, Pigott said. The same properties that make them resistant also mean they don’t decompose. Their “forever” properties contribute to the hazards associated with them, and they have been associated with adverse health effects on the liver, immune system, lipid levels, thyroid, kidney and low birth weight, according to the EPA.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here