Sunday, November 22, 2026
48 °
Light Rain
Log in Subscribe

Gov. Evers’ budget bill exempts PFAS from REINS Act

Posted

MARINETTE – A perceived lack of action on Wisconsin groundwater drinking water standards has energized Gov. Tony Evers to try a new tactic at getting PFAS regulations passed and implemented quickly that will exempt the rulemaking from a statute used to block funds meant to help clean up contaminations.

After repeated tries at setting limits for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances in groundwater used for drinking water have stalled, Evers is tucking a new clean-water plan with $145 million for PFAS remediation exempted from the REINS Act into the 2025-27 budget bill scheduled to be introduced Feb. 18, according to a recording of a Feb. 4 discussion Evers had with leaders in Marinette.

Many environmental advocates say the REINS Act – or the 2017 Regulations from the Executive in Need of Scrutiny Act – must be dealt with for PFAS to be addressed. Evers has come up with what he hopes will work: an exemption.
The REINS Act is designed to provide more oversight of rules with implementation and compliance costs of $10 million or more by allowing for independent economic impact analysis to be conducted and for the rules’ financial impact can be more closely scrutinized. The $125 million the state was to spend on PFAS remediation are included in the $145 million in Evers’ latest plan for PFAS cleanup.

Evers’ visit to Marinette was part of a cross-state campaign for clean water Evers and DNR Secretary Karen Hyun, who was appointed to the role in December, made to Marinette Feb. 4. They met with four members of Save Our Water (S.O.H2O) and other local leaders. Evers gave a sneak-preview of what the budget bill does for PFAS remediation and he listened to concerns and ideas for ways to address a known PFAS contamination of groundwater used for drinking water in the Town of Peshtigo.

“He’s got his budget bill ready to go. In it will be $145 million for PFAS and safe water -- that includes $120 million from the last budget plus interest,” and another $10 million, said Cindy Boyle, a clean water proponent who with her husband Chuck attended the Marinette meeting. Boyle said she had a hard time hearing what Evers said.

Other Marinette leaders who sat and talked with Evers included Marinette Mayor Steve Genisot, Marinette Common Council Member Doug Oitzinger, Marinette County Supervisor and former State Rep. Stan Gruszynski, Educator Wendy Dzurick and S.O.H2O member Trygve Rhude.

Boyle said she got a phone call the day before Evers visit with a request to attend. Not in attendance was Republican state Sen. Eric Wimberger, who sent Evers a letter in December asking for his help in writing legislation that would explain how innocent landowners would be exempt from the Spill Law, which states possessors of contaminated property can be held responsible.

Wimberger (R-Oconto) said he working on a rewrite of State Bill 312, which Evers vetoed last year, and he has invited Evers to work with him on new language, he said.

In learning Evers planned to include PFAS remediation in the budget, Wimberger said Feb. 4, “I’ve been waiting for months for the Governor to clarify his definition of an ‘innocent landowner,’ and he has refused to respond to my requests. This delay is holding up meaningful solutions to PFAS problems affecting communities across our state. I find myself sitting at the table waiting to have a meaningful conversation on how we can pass a bill to fight PFAS in Wisconsin, and I hope the Governor will join us there soon.”

A groundwater standard proposed several years ago that wasn’t enacted is set to expire March 12, putting pressure on Evers administration to come up with standards that can be implemented. In a Feb. 4 statement, state Rep. Lori Palmeri (D-Oshkosh) said the majority party’s lack of action was the reason groundwater standards for drinking water hadn’t been passed. “This marks the 12th time DNR has requested groundwater standards since Wisconsin’s groundwater law went into effect in the 1980s,” Palmeri said.

But Republicans say Evers hasn’t been willing to sit down with them. “I am hopeful this is a sign that the Governor will soon come to the table for an actual discussion about how to best support Wisconsinites impacted by these chemicals,” Felzskowski said in a statement.

Among the proposals in Evers’ plan are $145 million to address PFAS contamination through a Community Grant Program for municipal drinking water systems, a County Well-Testing Grant Program for private well owners, grants for businesses and local communities to reduce PFAS use, $2 million to provide safe bottled water to impacted communities, and $7 million in funding to help innocent landowners and farmers remediate PFAS contaminations.

Evers also wants to expand eligibility in the Well Compensation Grant program to help more households pay for treatment systems for private wells. The Chemical Level Enforcement and Remediation (CLEAR) Act aims to improve water quality by exempting DNR PFAS rulemaking from the REINS Act and barring biosolids containing high levels of PFAS from being spread on farmland used for agriculture. The Safe Drinking Water Loan program also would prioritize municipal applications that have PFAS levels exceeding standards.

Evers’ office has announced a push for standards in groundwater for six different PFAS, including perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA); perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS); perfluorohexane sulfonic acid (PFHxS); perfluorononanoic acid (PFNA), perfluorobutane sulfonic acid (PFBS), and hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (HFPO-DA), also referred to as GenX Chemicals.

These are the same six PFAS a federal rule sets regulations for, requiring public water systems throughout the nation to test drinking water for those contaminants and treat for them as necessary, according to the Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul, who joined the attorneys general of 18 states in signing an amicus brief Jan. 23 in support of the U.S. EPA’s efforts to expand PFAS regulations in drinking water.

The exact limits for the various PFAS weren’t announced, but Evers said they would be the same as the federal standards.

“I would love to see a more protective standard – I would like to see zero,” Boyle said. “Some protection is better than no protection. When it comes to groundwater, we’ve had no protection and it’s not OK.”

Boyle said PFAS remediation is an issue with bipartisan support. “I’m genuinely on board with anybody who wants to make forward progress on safe standards for PFAS,” she said. “ I just want people for once in their life to be authentic and be honest about it. PFAS are not partisan. Compromise has to be accomplished.”

Boyle is a former Town of Peshtigo Town Board chair. Under her leadership, the Town of Peshtigo filed a lawsuit against Johnson Controls in 2022 for a PFAS contamination it has taken some responsibility for.

While the litigation seems to be moving slowly, Boyle said she sees progress elsewhere, including in the way insurance companies are indirectly supporting PFAS bans by failing to insure against them. “Hopefully that will continue to drive market change,” she told a Peshtigo Times reporter.

“My insurance company is saying, ‘No PFAS will be covered by your business liability insurance,’” Boyle said. “If companies are no longer protected by their insurance liability, they’re not going to bare that exposure by themselves. Maybe they’ll think twice about using it (PFAS).”

Asked about an outright ban of PFAS, Boyle said, states like Minnesota are leading the way with a comprehensive ban on PFAS under Amara’s Law, which took effect in January and banned PFAS in 11 categories of consumer products sold or distributed in the state. The law expands the ban to more product categories over time.

The law is named after Amara Strande, a young woman whose death at age 20 from cancer is thought to be associated with PFAS exposure related to 3M’s use of the substances, Boyle said.

The tactic Evers is taking with the budget bill speaks to the challenge of not only passing legislation but also getting it implemented. This is a point attorney Colin Roth made before the Wisconsin Supreme Court in representing the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources in its fight against the Wisconsin Manufacturers Commerce Inc. and Leather Rich Inc. The case centers on Wisconsin’s Spill Law and how much authority the DNR should be given for PFAS spills.

While the Wisconsin Supreme Court case is pending, Evers is wasting no time with a new strategy for getting PFAS legislation on the books and implemented.

groundwater, drinking water standards, Gov. Tony Evers, PFAS, regulations, rulemaking, local leaders, Marinette, REINS Act, Boyle, Oitzinger, Wimberger, Palmeri, Felzskowski

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here