Sunday, November 22, 2026
48 °
Light Rain
Log in Subscribe

District and legal counsel refuse request to release survey responses

Posted

CRIVITZ – On May 30, the Peshtigo Times contacted Superintendent Kelly Robinson with a request for information on how coaches are selected and data on the number of parents who are coaches or assistant coaches.

Robinson said, “This past school year, the only sport provided at Crivitz High School and Crivitz Middle School that did not have at least one parent serving as a coach was the cross country team. The district is very fortunate to have so many parents eager and willing to serve as coaches; otherwise, we would not be able to provide [this] extent and depth of programs.”

The Peshtigo Times also asked for the responses to the student-athlete survey.

In a letter received June 6 from the school district’s legal counsel, Anthony Steffek at law firm Renning, Lewis & Lacy said the request for survey results was denied. Steffek said this was because the survey pertained to a district employee’s performance and survey respondents were told their responses were confidential.

Steffek said he used what’s known as “the balancing test” in determining “the public’s interest in nondisclosure clearly and significantly outweighs the public’s interest in disclosure” of the survey results.

Steffek referenced the case of Hempel v. City of Baraboo, in which the Wisconsin Supreme Court delivered a 2005 opinion upholding Baraboo’s right to deny a police officer’s request for records from an internal investigation about his alleged sexual harassment of female officers. Baraboo said providing the requested documents would have “a chilling effect” on its internal investigations involving employees, according to a FindLaw.com summary.

In this matter, however, the Peshtigo Times didn’t request the names of the students or of the coaches, but only the survey responses. Several Crivitz parents also have requested surveys of all athletic teams at the end of the season.

Another Wisconsin Supreme Court case about access to information sided with the media. In the case of Newspapers, Inc. v. Breier, the Wisconsin Supreme Court in a May 30, 1979 opinion said a local police chief was required to make records available to the press and the public, including the charge involved in making an arrest, according to Justia.com

Steffek said revealing the survey responses could have a “chilling effect” on candid student responses on surveys. This means the students might be less willing to provide candid responses out of a concern their comments could be traced to them, putting them at risk of retaliation.

At least two student athletes spoke during public input at Crivitz School Board meetings this spring about a disappointing season.

Despite the comments being made publicly, the Peshtigo Times didn’t publish the students’ names to protect their privacy because of their age and the sensitivity of the comments.

However, in the 1995 U.S. Supreme Court case of McIntyre v Ohio Election Commission, the court struck down a state law that banned distribution of anonymous campaign literature by saying the First Amendment allowed for anonymous speech.

In its questions for the school district, the Peshtigo Times asked why boys teams weren’t surveyed, as some parents had raised issues related to a “good ole boy” network and coaches tolerating and using inappropriate language demeaning to women. The Peshtigo Times didn’t receive a response to this question.

While some parents had suggested surveying all students to obtain more information and to reduce the likelihood of identifying individual students from the larger body of anonymous responses, the school district opted not to go this route.

Steffek said, “Disclosing comments elicited with the expectation of confidentiality only serves to erode the trust and credibility of the District’s Board of Education and administration with students, which must be avoided.”

However, police departments and other public bodies routinely redact or cloak information given to the media, such as the names of juveniles.

Steffek also said, “There is no value to the public in receiving such content that, again, is subjective, often misleading and potentially premised on inaccurate or incomplete information, and, in this case, provided by students.”

However, opinion commentary is often protected under the First Amendment, including students’ expression of opinions or stances.

In the 1969 U.S. Supreme Court case of Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, the nation’s highest court said students “do not shed their constitutional rights at the schoolhouse gate,” according to a summary the American Library Association provided. The First Amendment protects public students’ right to express their views. For a public school district to obstruct this right could be viewed as censorship.

While denying the Peshtigo Times’ request for the survey responses, Steffek said they could be used “for internal management and evaluation purposes.”

Superintendent Kelly Robinson, Crivitz High School and Crivitz Middle School, student responses, athlete surveys, public records

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here